Elevens Premier League Penalty Takers: Who Is on Penalties at Every Club
Who takes the penalties at every club in Elevens Premier League, and how sure that is. A nailed penalty taker has a much higher points ceiling than a similar player without spot-kick duty.
For each club we show the model's first-choice taker and the next in line, with the share of the club's penalties each is expected to take this round. The share moves when the regular taker is injured, rested or suspended, so it always reflects who is expected on the pitch.
Below that: who took each club's most recent corners, direct free kicks and penalties, from match data.
Penalty takers for every club - Gameweek 11
The surest penalty takers for Gameweek 11 are Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United, 99%), Erling Haaland (Manchester City, 94%), Dominic Calvert-Lewin (Leeds United, 91%), Cole Palmer (Chelsea, 91%), Enzo Le Fee (Sunderland, 89%).
Duty is split at 2 clubs: Everton between James Garner and Thierno Barry; Ipswich Town between Zian Flemming and Jack Clarke.
Share = the part of the club's penalties our model expects each player to take in Gameweek 11, given who is expected to play. It is a projection, recomputed as team news lands, not a count of penalties already taken.
| Club | First-choice taker | Share | Next in line | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AFC Bournemouth | Justin Kluivert | 75% | Elie Kroupi | 15% |
| Arsenal | Martin Ødegaard | 73% | Viktor Gyökeres | 27% |
| Aston Villa | John McGinn | 84% | Emiliano Buendia | 16% |
| Brentford | Mathias Jensen | 69% | Kevin Schade | 28% |
| Brighton & Hove Albion | Pascal Gross | 88% | Diego Gomez | 9% |
| Chelsea | Cole Palmer | 91% | Estevao | 9% |
| Coventry City | Victor Torp | 73% | Brandon Thomas-Asante | 22% |
| Crystal Palace | Jørgen Strand Larsen | 64% | Edward Nketiah | 21% |
| Everton | James Garner | 46% | Thierno Barry | 45% |
| Fulham | Gonzalo Garcia | 85% | Oscar Bobb | 15% |
| Hull City | Oliver McBurnie | 88% | Joe Gelhardt | 12% |
| Ipswich Town | Zian Flemming | 42% | Jack Clarke | 41% |
| Leeds United | Dominic Calvert-Lewin | 91% | Lukas Nmecha | 9% |
| Liverpool | Dominik Szoboszlai | 70% | Alexander Isak | 30% |
| Manchester City | Erling Haaland | 94% | Iliman Ndiaye | 4% |
| Manchester United | Bruno Fernandes | 99% | Bryan Mbeumo | 1% |
| Newcastle United | Yoane Wissa | 56% | Harvey Barnes | 30% |
| Nottingham Forest | Morgan Gibbs-White | 87% | Chris Wood | 13% |
| Sunderland | Enzo Le Fee | 89% | Chemsdine Talbi | 11% |
| Tottenham Hotspur | Dominic Solanke | 63% | Mohammed Kudus | 37% |
Projections last updated 2026-11-16 21:47 UTC.
Set-piece takers: corners, free kicks and penalties
Who actually took each club's set pieces most recently, from match data: the last corner takers (up to two - most clubs use one per side), the last direct free-kick shooter and the last penalty taker. Penalty shootouts are left out.
Most recent penalties: Pascal Gross (Brighton & Hove Albion, 2026-11-08); John McGinn (Aston Villa, 2026-11-08); Jack Clarke (Ipswich Town, 2026-11-08); Enzo Le Fee (Sunderland, 2026-11-08).
This is what happened on the pitch, not a projection. The penalty table above is the model's view of who takes the next one; when the two disagree, the regular taker was usually off the pitch.
| Club | Corners | Direct free kicks | Last penalty |
|---|---|---|---|
| AFC Bournemouth | Marcus Tavernier, Justin Kluivert | Marcus Tavernier | Lewis Cook |
| Arsenal | Martin Ødegaard, Declan Rice | Martin Ødegaard | Bukayo Saka |
| Aston Villa | John McGinn, Ibrahim Mbaye | Johan Manzambi | John McGinn |
| Brentford | Mathias Jensen, Keane Lewis-Potter | Mathias Jensen | Thiago Rodrigues |
| Brighton & Hove Albion | Pascal Gross, Maxim De Cuyper | Maxim De Cuyper | Pascal Gross |
| Chelsea | Pedro Neto, Estevao | Morgan Rogers | Cole Palmer |
| Coventry City | Jack Rudoni, Victor Torp | Victor Torp | Jack Rudoni |
| Crystal Palace | Yéremi Pino, Adam Wharton | Yéremi Pino | Edward Nketiah |
| Everton | James Garner, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall | James Garner | James Garner |
| Fulham | Alex Iwobi, Oscar Bobb | Oscar Bobb | Antonee Robinson |
| Hull City | Mohamed-Ali Cho, Regan Slater | Oliver McBurnie | Oliver McBurnie |
| Ipswich Town | Jack Clarke, Leif Davis | Julio Enciso | Jack Clarke |
| Leeds United | Sean Longstaff, Harry Wilson | Harry Wilson | Dominic Calvert-Lewin |
| Liverpool | Dominik Szoboszlai, Milos Kerkez | Dominik Szoboszlai | Cody Gakpo |
| Manchester City | Enzo Fernández, Rayan Cherki | Rayan Cherki | Erling Haaland |
| Manchester United | Bruno Fernandes, Bryan Mbeumo | Bruno Fernandes | Bruno Fernandes |
| Newcastle United | Jacob Murphy, Lewis Hall | Amar Dedic | Yoane Wissa |
| Nottingham Forest | Neco Williams, James McAtee | Neco Williams | Morgan Gibbs-White |
| Sunderland | Enzo Le Fee, Granit Xhaka | Enzo Le Fee | Enzo Le Fee |
| Tottenham Hotspur | Mohammed Kudus, Dejan Kulusevski | Pedro Porro | Mohammed Kudus |
Projections last updated 2026-11-17 06:52 UTC.
Frequently asked questions
Why do penalty takers matter in Elevens Premier League?
Penalties are high-probability goals. A first-choice penalty taker adds a reliable source of points and raises a player's ceiling, making him more valuable than a similar player without spot-kick duty.
What does the penalty share mean?
The share of his club's penalties a player is expected to take in the round. 90% means he is the clear taker; two players near 50% means the duty is genuinely shared, or that the usual taker may not start.